The Daily

Our Daily Correspondent

Truth in Advertising

January 29, 2016 | by

Calamityhorse3a47545u

Martha Jane Burke (“Calamity Jane”), on horseback in 1901. Photo: C. D. Arnold. Via United States Library of Congress

Another person is the best way to learn about a book. At least, it’s my favorite; good reviews are an art form, Web sites a modern marvel, but somehow my best-loved books have come directly from someone else’s recommendation, and the enthusiasm of those conversations is a pleasure in itself. It’s hard to overstate the importance of this particular chain of connection. When you think about it, most of the world’s great religions are based on book recommendation. 

I recently learned about the book I want to recommend to you today via someone whom I met while reporting a story. He, in turn, had been recommended the title by a horse trainer on a film set. Where that guy heard of it, I can’t say, but the chain is doubtless long—dating back, at any rate, to 1976, when Shameless Hussy Press published Calamity Jane’s Letters to Her Daughter

This book is allegedly formed of letters found after Martha Jane Cannary’s death. According to legend, the famed Wild West heroine taught herself to write in order to communicate with the daughter she’d given up for adoption, which explains the untutored spelling and grammar. But whether or not the book is genuine—many historians believe it unlikely—it’s wonderful: a historical document of the “Old West,”  yes, but also a very moving story of motherhood and real struggle. 

Calamity Jane was apparently known to be something of a fabulist—the brief autobiography she dictated in her lifetime is full of tall tales, and her professional storytelling was colorful—but even the known facts of her life were extraordinary. She was probably not involved in any Indian wars, and didn’t attack Wild Bill Hickok’s murderer with a cleaver. She may or may not have been a Pony Express driver, nurse, cook and saloon girl; she was probably a sometime prostitute; she was certainly a scout and a famed performer in Buffalo Bill’s traveling show, struggled with alcoholism, and died in her early fifties. Oh, and she also nursed smallpox patients in Deadwood and took the reins of a runaway stagecoach after the driver was shot. In other words, she lived hard, and she lived in a different America entirely. This book is a document of that, fiction or non, with all the ugliness and hate and adventure and change it implies. Calamity Jane herself wrote, “They are telling awful things about me. None of it is true.” At the end of the day, as she knew, it was all relative. 

I loved it. I hope you will read it, and if you do, I hope you will pass it along to someone else. 

Sadie Stein is contributing editor of The Paris Review, and the Daily’s correspondent.

2 COMMENTS

2 Comments

  1. alta | February 22, 2016 at 11:51 pm

    Jane Cannery Hickok lived in the late 19th century. Her life was very harsh in the Wild West, especially as a single woman. She found an honorable couple willing to raise her child. She requested that the letters be held until her death, and then given to her daughter Janey.

    She was self-educated, as were many pioneers; schools were rare, and only for children. Some towns had Scribes; literate people who would take dictation of personal letters, and help with documents. She probably wrote these letters herself as they are personal & heartfelt, and grammatically imperfect. In one letter, she mentions writing by the light of a campfire.

    Her daughter did receive the letters after Jane Cannary Hickok’s death. The daughter shared them with a friend, Stella A. Foote, who confirmed that Jane was real, her daughter Janey is real, and the letters are personal, intended to be private.

    However, Ms. Foote recognized that they were a historical treasure & contacted the Montana Historical Society, which published a number of them in a small edition. Producers of the film and the television show DEADWOOD based on this book contacted Ms. Foote and honored her claim to copyright, but she was adamant that Jane Cannary Hickok was the author, not Ms. Foote.

    I was able to locate a copy, and also to have access to additional letters not included in that first edition. Adding information from other archival documents, diaries and photos of the time, we compiled the book you now see.

    I appreciate Sadie Stein’s comment in The Paris Review that the Letters are “a very moving story of motherhood and real struggle.”

    We are reprinting CALAMITY JANE’S LETTERS TO HER DAUGHTER and are happy to see continued interest in this historical treasure.

    Alta , publisher
    Shameless Hussy Press
    Tough Old Lady Publications
    P.O. Box 5540, Berkeley CA 94705

    http://www.theparisreview.org/blog/2016/01/29/truth-in-advertising-2/

  2. Miss Lisa | February 27, 2016 at 2:14 am

    I’d read that!!

Leave a Comment