The Daily

On Music

Escapades Out on the D Train

November 26, 2012 | by

Going to a Bob Dylan gig these days requires a certain sort of mindset. Worship, obviously, but also a readiness not to see or hear anything pleasant for two hours. The greatest fan of Dylan I have ever met wears earplugs during his concerts. And Dylan’s voice on his latest album occasionally sounds terrifyingly close to a death rattle. Last week, by way of preparation for a performance at Brooklyn’s Barclays Center my friend put himself on an expectation-suppressing diet of the worst ever Dylan tracks. “I listened to ‘Let’s Stick Together’ from ‘Down in the Groove,’” he reported, “Awful. Just dreadful, and the worst CD sound imaginable. Loved it!”

Brooklyn was Dylan’s last stop on a thirty-three city U.S. tour. And moments into his first set, he had us all wondering once again what we were doing there. As if to underline this question, a mirror was set up, front of stage—face-out. Without any sort of greeting, Dylan entered under his white brimmed hat and croaked “You Ain’t Goin’ Nowhere” indecipherably from behind the keyboard. Only one word really came through: “Whoo-ee!” The earplugs went in next to me, the crowd dug in—silent, enduring. It looked like we were in for another terrible night, but as the song advanced one detected a devious energy in the delivery, a hint that he could give better. And he did—a lot better.

Old songs in new arrangements sounded as though they had just been written, and details to which he gave focused articulation, seemed alive with fresh experience. “Don’t Think Twice, It’s Alright”, drained of bitterness and self-pity, was sung with mischief, and gentle curiosity. Lines like “You could have done better / But I don’t mind” became almost forgiving. In a haunting rendition of “Visions of Johanna,” he brought immediacy to the smallest fragments of narrative, singing of the room where “the heat pipes just cough” as though he’d just come from a small cramped apartment in the Village. And even when Dylan misses a line, it can seem palpably present to a fan in the grip of aural madness. In the same song, I thought I heard him whisper of “escapades out on the D train” as vividly as though he might have taken the D train to the Barclays Center that evening, but Earplugs (can he lip read Dylan?) turned to me moments after and said, “Skipped a line”.

As usual, there were some bizarre moments, including an almost incomprehensible version of “Things Have Changed.” Singing it from center stage, he abandoned the puppet-like moves that have characterized his dancing in recent years for something that looked a bit like fencing—airy thrusts of the arm at a phantom enemy. But he was enjoying himself, or seemed to be, singing the lines “I used to care, but things have changed” with wicked abandon.

Alongside a run of vitally executed regulars—“Ballad of Thin Man,” “Like A Rolling Stone,” “All Along the Watchtower”—recent works commanded their own atmosphere. In “Early Roman Kings” the air felt filthy with power and violence, and the band stomped through the song like a menacing assembly of imperial thugs. And perhaps best of all was an intimate, plaintive rendition of “Forgetful Heart,” accompanied by Donnie Herron on viola and punctuated with beautifully plangent harmonica playing from Dylan.

The band was as tight an ensemble as Dylan has had—some of the greatest sidemen in the world, expert Dylan-minders consummate in every genre and able to decipher even his most cryptic moves. But there were few opportunities for them to shine. I have seen Charlie Sexton step forward and play virtuosic guitar solos in the past, but on Wednesday night, he and his bandmates cowered in dark corners of the stage like diffident teenagers. It seemed that they were watching Dylan. Not just watching him because they were waiting for a cue or because they didn’t know what he would do next. They seemed to be watching Dylan like we were watching Dylan—amazed, scared, thrilled, grateful that, beneath all the layers of masquerade, this seventy-one-year-old was still getting up there night after night, still pulsing with authenticity, still doing just as he averred aged twenty-two—“I’ll tell it and speak it and think it and breathe it.” And—for now, at least—Dylan looks like this is exactly what he wants to be doing. Last week, more than ever, he seemed like the eponymous hero of his song, Handy Dandy, a sinister mingling of fop and rogue, insouciance and disquiet; “He’s been round the world and back again / Something in the moonlight still hounds him.”

Adelaide Docx is a British-born writer in New York City. She is the former American Associate Editor of Granta. Her short fiction has been published by N+1 and Shakespeare & Co’s Paris Magazine, and she has written short book reviews for The New Yorker and Time Out. She is an agent for classical musicians, and is working on her first novel, The Sabbatical.



  1. Gui | November 26, 2012 at 11:19 am

    Your experience with a Dylan show mirrors my own. I haven’t seen him since 2007, but the first song in that set made me suppose we were in for a long night. We were, but not that way. Dylan sang in about 6 different voices over the course of the evening, leading one to suppose that his garbled, ruined, incomprehensible voice was just a pose…given he came and went from it as if from one room to another and back as the light changed.

    On the subject of earplugs, I can tell you that I wear them at all the shows I go to or play. Good ones make concerts less painful and *more* audible for us quadragenarians out there (c’est moi!). “You’ll understand when you’re older,” is the annoying thing someone (pas moi!) would say at this point right here.

    Anyhoo, lovely piece.

  2. Jeanne Jett | November 28, 2012 at 6:09 am

    Absolutely brilliantly written! I saw Bob on September 15 of this year and I don’t think I blinked through the entire show. I was in Heaven and I knew it. I cried with unabondened joy when he came on stage. There he was. So close, if I stood up, I could touch him. So alive and full of smiles, he was having fun. I was totally mesmerized. He’s the Master of them all. I don’t care how old he is. I’ve been going to his concerts for over 40 years and that same out of this world feeling comes over every single time. Keep Rockin’ Bobby. I’ll be right there~♥

  3. Larry Shapiro | November 28, 2012 at 4:14 pm

    I can confirm that he flubbed the D train line. No need to be able to read lips. I could hear the lyrics. I feel that I corrected the error when I took the D train home from the show.

  4. James S. | December 3, 2012 at 11:25 pm

    Great review, thanks. I was at the same show. Dylan’s voice is simply gone — or am I missing something? I felt the band made up for it, and it was a good show.

  5. Basil Anova | December 4, 2012 at 12:15 am

    You get it, Adelaide. Thank you.

  6. Irwin Grossman | December 4, 2012 at 9:18 am

    Saw the Boston show. In a word, terrible. Sounded like he was barking for help from the bottom of a well. Arrangements incomprehensible. And I’m a fan. Blind worship can only take one so far.

  7. beejeez | December 4, 2012 at 11:08 am

    Seeing Dylan these days is sort of like touring a museum where a layer of dust has accumulated on all the works. The art is harder to see, faded and smudged. But seeing it firsthand can move you in ways that seeing it only in pristine reproductions can’t capture.

  8. Chris | December 4, 2012 at 3:35 pm

    I’ve seen Dylan every couple of years since ’78 and the show I saw in September was one of the best I’ve seen. Yes, he has smoked his voice away. Yet, somehow, he gets by with guile and joy, like an aging pitcher who’s lost his fastball and needs to get the hitters out with his wits. It was a beautiful performance.

  9. Paul | December 4, 2012 at 10:54 pm

    It is an odd position to be a Dylan fan nowadays. The issues with the singing voice I can bear. I can understand, from a musicians standpoint, the boredom of singing the same songs for decades.

    The thing that annoys me to no end is the complete re-write of the arrangements of songs. I’m not looking for a verbatim rendition of the songs I grew up with. I expect a new interpretation or tangent in some respect as the song is played.

    Yet, to completely disregard the arrangement of a well-known song as to make it unrecognizable is unforgivable to me. For what else is the the song but the intricate arrangement of melody to word to performance? Having been to a Dylan concert recently, I had to wonder why I even went. This wasn’t the songs I grew to love. They were almost bad covers by someone I never heard of before.

    Ray Charles must’ve sung ‘Georgia on my Mind’ 50,000+ times. I bet it was never sung exactly the same time, ever. Yet, I bet you’d always know what song he was singing when he finished.

  10. oelioe | May 24, 2015 at 3:25 pm

    I did not read your text
    But I have idea your writing is less to do with actual Dylan. It is only some trend of people you do not like(obviously).
    And lastly I think you should be clever enough to admit people born live and die and things related with stages of life are never the same.

  11. Dave Wisker | May 24, 2015 at 5:18 pm

    We saw his Kansas City show. Loved the performance, quirky and spry. And that band was hot.

  12. Pete Jameson | May 25, 2015 at 9:05 am

    Nice approximation of the Dylan experience. Saw him in ’04 & ’08 – though he gave the band their moments to shine back then. He seemed to bristle at the criticism of his “singing” in his Music Cares speech earlier this year. A telling line from “Things Have Changed” – “I hurt easy, I just don’t show it…”

1 Pingbacks

  1. […] Earplugged Posted at 9:00 on December 3, 2012 by Andrew Sullivan   Adelaide Docx captures the experience of seeing the aging rockstar in concert: Going to a Bob Dylan gig these days […]

Leave a Comment