The Daily

Ask The Paris Review

Advice to Our Scottish Readers

August 19, 2011 | by

Late last Tuesday night, a crowd gathered in an antique circus tent, in Edinburghs Charlotte Square, to shelter from the rain, drink whiskey, and hear readings by Paris Review contributor Donald Antrim and Southern editor John Jeremiah Sullivan, both introduced by editor Lorin Stein. The program—The Paris Review Presents New American Writing at the Edinburgh Book Fair—received mixed reviews. One tweeter called itbloomin superb. A blogger asked, Why cant there be events like this in Edinburgh all the time? One young festival volunteer, less enthusiastically, described it as wordy. What did she expect? Last year when McSweeneys came, the editor got up on stage and shaved his head.

For some, head shaving is not an option. Instead, at the end of the night, the Paris Review delegates opened the floor to requests for advice, which were submitted on scraps of paper. Most were answered on the spot; others were tucked into a notebook and reviewed on the road, as editors Sullivan and Stein recuperated from the book fair triumph/fiasco.

Could you recommend a travel book about either Japan or Spain?

We are composing this response under deadline in the West Highlands—specifically, in the self-proclaimed “oldest pub in Scotland,” the Lachlann Inn, on the banks of Loch Lomond. As everyone knows, they didn’t have WiFi in 1734 (although they do appear to have had video poker). For this reason, we can’t answer your question in the kind of depth that American readers have come to expect from The Paris Review. We can only recommend, in Lorin’s case, Robert Hughes’s Barcelona and, in John’s case, Journey of a Thousand Miles, the famous series of travel haiku by Basho. (John would also like to recommend the Laura Veirs song “Rapture,” which is not strictly speaking a travelogue, but does include a tribute to “lovely Basho / his plunking ponds and toads.”)

Please recommend a good book for our book club. We are currently reading Jennifer Egans novel A Visit From the Goon Squad and have recently read such books as So Much for That, The Dice Man, Middlesex, Half of a Yellow Sun, Oryx and Crake, and Rebecca.
—Marion & Co.

When we see the title The Dice Man, we both think of the scandal-plagued comedian of our youth, the “Dice Man,” Andrew Dice Clay—and that can’t possibly be what you have in mind. Still, we are struck by the breadth of your reading. Your question has been on our minds. Yesterday we wandered into a small used bookstore at the foot of the Castle mound and both ogled a complete 1910 Robert Louis Stevenson in twenty volumes. John proposed that we donate it to your book club; Lorin found it “too rich” for The Paris Review’s “blood.” As a backup, John recommends Ghost Light, Joseph O’Connor’s fictional re-creation of John Millington Synge’s hopeless love affair with the Abbey Theatre actress Molly Allgood. And we both recommend—in the strongest possible terms—our colleague Donald Antrim’s short novel The Verficationist, about an academic meeting gone horribly wrong amid the hustle and bustle of an International House of Pancakes.

How can I stop being such a sad young literary man?
—Anna Feintuck
s companion

Time will take care of that more quickly than you think. Believe us.

Have a question for The Paris Review? E-mail us.



  1. M.M. | August 22, 2011 at 12:03 pm

    The circus tent makes more sense than it should.

  2. Doug | August 22, 2011 at 12:08 pm

    Aren’t all circus tents antique?

  3. Eamon O'Byrne | August 22, 2011 at 5:59 pm

    I recommend V.S. Pritchett’s “Marching Spain” as wonderfully sensuous introduction to the Spanish landscape.

  4. Stoney Hando | August 23, 2011 at 8:03 am

    I understand you left Edinburgh with a copy of the One O’Clock Gun Anthology, quintessential Edinburgh grassroots publishing, thanks! The event was a triumph thanks for blessing the spot X

  5. Barbara Delaney | July 22, 2012 at 6:01 pm

    “Journey of a Thousand Miles” is by the pianint Lang Lang. Basho wrote “Narrow Road to the Interior”.

  6. Barbara Delaney | July 22, 2012 at 6:02 pm


  7. Norman Reeley | September 25, 2013 at 5:45 pm

    Hi Lorin/john,
    I was there at the Edinburgh event… the only real criticism is that you were drinking whisky as in Scotch, and not whiskey as in Irish!
    Otherwise a great Book Festival all round!

Leave a Comment